🎨 Ad Creative
Four types of ad creative kicked ass, according to Matt:
- Memes
- TikTok/UGC style videos
- Informal Banners
- Testimonials
We’ll break down each in turn. As we do, notice how the different ads all convey the same three things: What The Milk Road writes about, social proof, and the fact that it’s free.
1. Memes: More art than science, you can find meme templates on imgFlip to use for your own brand.
2. TikTok/UGC style videos: Paid micro-influencers and creators on UpWork for 20-30 second vertical videos, with a hook in the first five seconds (typically $80-$100/video).
Matt’s basic rules for great videos:
- Have a hook in the first five seconds
- Show how the newsletter solves a specific problem the reader has
- Show social proof
- Strong call to action
- If the newsletter is free, say that
You can see all their current ads here.
3. (Very) informal banners: “Literally just like, write some good copy in your iPhone notes app, take a screenshot of that, and use that as an ad,” Matt said.
The point is just to create something that doesn’t look like a typical ad. Something that will grab attention through its informality.
You can also:
- Use Notion
- Put text on a black or white background in Canva
- Write it on a legal pad
4. Testimonials: The team would ask readers to tweet about the newsletter, then screenshot those tweets and use them as ad creative. That's it.
💳 Budget
Finally, a word on budget: You don’t need much.
Shaan and Ben were ready to spend well into the six-figures on acquisition. But Matt said that $30 per day is enough to get you started.
All Facebook ads go through something called a “learning phase,” where the algorithm tests and optimizes the audience to see who is best to target.
To graduate from the learning phase, your ads need ~50 conversions per week. If you budget $3-$4 per conversion, that’s ~$150-$200 in ad spend.
So $30 per day, seven days a week will get you your 50 required conversions.
It should actually get you more than that, Matt said, because the typical conversion cost for a free newsletter subscriber is well below $4 – closer to $1.50 if you have your landing page on-point.
Final note: Shaan's great. His "5 Tweet Tuesday" emails bring a cry-laugh to my face. He recently launched a blogging project called Good Friday, where he emails back and forth with cool folks and publishes the whole thing. Bold move — but a delicious read, always.